Resolutions: what is a valid amendment to be voted on?

0 votes

Some confusion at our latest  Council meeting. A proposal was made, and seconded, to accept a Planning Application. No debate had taken place at that time. Opponents to this immediately proposed what appeared to be the exact opposite. The second proposal was allowed and voted on. The chair then  ruled that we did not need to vote on the primary proposal as it was a direct negative. 

However Councillors have complained that the Chair acted incorrectly: the secondary proposal was invalid as it should have represented an amendment to the first and shown to be in basic agreement. The two (primary and amendment) should then have been voted on separately. The arguments continue.

Could someone advise please? 

asked by (2.5k points)

1 Answer

0 votes
Best answer
What do your standing orders say? I would certainly expect that a resolution, properly put forward and seconded, should be dealt with (including amendments if proposed) before another resolution is proposed and voted on.
answered by (1.6k points)
selected by
Thanks for your comment. In the event the negative of the Resolution was voted on before the Proposer and Seconder had been able to speak.  Now the issue is: as Standing Orders specifically says that the negative of the Primary resolution is not a valid amendment (quite rightly): is the vote that was carried (8 for, 8 against with the Chair casing vote) valid? I suspect there is nothing that can be done about it. The argument is that the same result would have happened. I am not so sure.

Welcome to Town & Parish Councillor Q&A, where you can ask questions and receive answers from other members of the community. All genuine questions and answers are welcome. Follow us on Twitter to see the latest questions - use the button above or follow @TownCouncilQA. Posts from new members may be delayed as we are unfortunately obliged to check each one for spam. Spammers will be blacklisted.

You may find the following links useful:

We have a privacy policy and a cookie policy.

Categories

Google Analytics Alternative