Thanks, you for your response, re 'in this day and age an email is acceptable' that may be so, but does this comply with the Law, and your comment I totally agree make sense 'I would simply check with the person' I would have thought this would be a simple safeguard. Obviously, the councillor in question if safeguards were in place could have been in a position to confirm he did not send the email, however he was at odds with both the Clerk and Chairman and although he responded to the Clerks acceptance email back to him within literally minutes of receiving it they then referred to the correct procedure that once they had received it tuff. Problem really is this and seeing other comments once a rouge council always a rough council and no one to appeal to.